Every Oil Shock Is Followed by a Recession. But Not for the Reason You Think
A landmark study by Ben Bernanke — the man who went on to run the Federal Reserve — found that it wasn't oil shocks that caused recessions. It was the interest rate hikes that followed. The central bank's reaction did more damage than the oil shock itself.
We call it the "double brake." The oil shock hits the economy first. Then the central bank raises rates on top. Two brakes on an economy already slowing down.
Right now, with the Strait of Hormuz closed, oil above $108, and gas fields burning in the Gulf, the Bank of England faces exactly this dilemma. The UK economy is growing at zero. Unemployment is at a 10-year high. Vacancies have collapsed below pre-pandemic levels. Wage growth is slowing. The conditions for a wage-price spiral do not exist.
And yet the Bank of England's cutting cycle has stalled — and some are calling for rate rises — because of an energy shock the Bank has no power to fix.
In this episode, Jon Adair and Neil Woodford explain the Bernanke research, apply it to the UK economy, and discuss what it means for anyone with a mortgage, savings, a pension, or investments in the UK.
Referenced in this episode: "Systematic Monetary Policy and the Effects of Oil Price Shocks" — Ben S. Bernanke, Mark Gertler, Mark Watson. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1:1997. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/1997/01/1997a_bpea_bernanke_gertler_watson_sims_friedman.pdf
More episodes
UK Inflation Will Stay at 3% — Here’s Why the Market Is Wrong
UK inflation is falling while oil is up 35% and gilt yields are at an 18-year high. Neil Woodford explains why the 4-5% inflation forecasts are wrong again, what is actually in the CPI basket, and why the bond market may be pricing the wrong story.
Show notesBritain’s Productivity Crisis: A Great Deception?
Is the UK's productivity crisis actually real? The ONS has quietly admitted its Labour Force Survey overstated UK employment, and the HMRC tax data tells a completely different story about the UK economy, your taxes and interest rates. In this episode, Neil Woodford explains what the tax records really show about UK productivity, why the official survey invented half a million workers who don't exist, and how one wrong number fed both the OBR forecast that drove Rachel Reeves' tax rises and the Bank of England's view of how fast the economy can grow before rates must stay high. We also get into the collapse in graduate jobs and what it says about AI adoption in the UK, whether Britain's productivity has genuinely accelerated since 2024, and how the UK really compares with the G7. Stay to the end for what a correction means for the November Budget, mortgage rates, gilts and rate-sensitive UK stocks, and where Neil sees the opportunity. Read Neil's full written analysis Neil's first piece on this from 2024
Show notesThe 7 Decisions Every Investor Faces (Part 1)
Neil Woodford has been answering questions about investing for 35 years – and every one of them comes down to seven decisions. In part one of this three-part series, Neil and Jon Adair cover the funnel: the three decisions that take you from every company in the world down to a shortlist worth owning.
Show notesGo deeper than the podcast
Access the strategies, research, and real-time portfolio data behind the conversations.
